ATI’s Greatest Hits Volume 2

Judy Fitzgerald

A proud member of Actors Equity Association. Credits include Radio City Music Hall with Glen Close; Madison Square Garden with Liza Minnelli & Danny Burstein (conducted by Marvin Hamlisch): She has toured nationally with Debbie Reynolds, Shirley Jones & Omar Sharif. Off -Broadway: Swingtime Canteen with Tony Award winner, Charles Busch at the Blue Angel; Placido Domingo’s operetta VLAD at the Lamb’s Theatre; Dodsworth with John Collum, George Lee Andrews & Dee Hoty at the York Theatre and the John Houseman Theatre; Irene at the Sylvia & Danny Kaye Playhouse; and Face the Music & That’s The Ticket! with Tony Award winner, George S. Irving for “Musicals Tonight!”  Other credits include Regional, Summer Stock, Dinner Theatre, Cabaret, Symphony Concerts….  Judy is one of the Co-Founders of Actors Theatre of Indiana.  A native of Indiana and long- time resident of NYC, she currently resides in Carmel. For more information on Judy, visit: atistage.org

Cynthia Collins

A proud member of Actors Equity Association since 1991, credits include: Off-Broadway, National & International Tours, Regional, Summer Stock, Cabaret, Dinner Theatre, Cruise Lines, Film & TV….  She has had the pleasure of working with such artists as: Ben Vereen, Sandy Duncan, Claude Aikins, Comden & Green, Cy Coleman, Avery Schrieber, Joel Grey, Cyndi Lauper, Fred Waring & His Famous Pennsylvanians, Chita Rivera, Sutton Foster, Jerry Michell, Diane Rehm, Billy Stritch, Patricia Wilson, George S. Irving, Sergio Trujillo, Richard Riehle…. Cindy is Co-Founder Emeritus of Actors Theatre of Indiana. A Native of N.J. and long- time resident of NYC, She currently resides in Carmel. 

Emily Davis

Emily Davis is so excited to return to the stage with ATI, having performed as Olive in 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee in 2018. She is a process-driven performer, voice teacher, and musician. She co-owns The Davis Academy of Music in Bloomington, IN, with her husband, Craig. As an actor, her favorite credits include The Baker’s Wife in Sondheim’s Into the Woods (IUST), Kate in Calling All Kates (BPP/ATF); and Amy in Sondheim’s Company (IU). Notably, she was also seen as Hermione in Winter’s Tale, Death in Everybody, Maria in Twelfth Night, and Holly in Bowling for Beginners during her time pursuing her master’s degree at IU. She’s performed off-broadway, at Lincoln Center, and internationally in Florence, Italy. She holds a Bachelor of Music in Vocal Performance from New York University-Steinhardt and an MFA in Acting. If you’d like to catch more of her work, you can check her out at www.emilymdavis.com. IG: @emily_michele TT: @emilydavisactor 

Suzanne Stark

Suzanne Stark is delighted to recreate a moment as Mother Superior from one of her favorite shows, Nunsense. ATI audiences may also remember Suzanne Stark as Lita Encore from their production of Ruthless and as the mother in the Lab Series Reading of Hollywood, Nebraska, but frankly, playing nuns is a habit she can’t break! In 1978 Suzanne played a nun onstage for the first time in Sound of Music. Since then, she has been the SOM Mother Abbess 3 times and that failed-nun Maria Von Trapp twice plus the stern and proper Mother Superior in Sister Act. Yes, she does play nuns, but in real life she has 3 children and 8 grandchildren!

As an Equity actress, for over 40 years she has had the pleasure of inhabiting diverse leading roles, primarily at Beef & Boards Dinner Theatre – most recently as Mrs. Peacock in Clue, Dolly Levi in Hello Dolly, Clairee Belcher in Steel Magnolias, Carlotta in Phantom, the aforementioned Mother Abbess and Mrs. Schubert in Shear Madness, to name a few – and now Suzanne is grateful to be back in the habit again! 

When she is not on the stage, as an award winning photographer and artist, she is also the owner/operator of Suzanne Stark Portrait Studio in Noblesville.

Diana O’Halloran

Diana is thrilled to be back with ATI for this wonderful show.

Previous credits include Jeannie Douglas in ATI’s production of Mr. Confidential, the original production of Witness Uganda at the Rattlestick Theater and One of Us at the York Theatre Company in New York City. She will be playing Claire in American Lives Theatre’s upcoming production of Natural Affection in January. Diana has a Bachelors of Music degree from Manhattan School of Music and is a voice teacher here in Carmel.

Lizzie Farrell

Lizzie is currently a Freshman at Indiana University, majoring in  Psychology and Theatre. Credits include: Be More Chill (University Players), Mean Girls , Revue! (YAP program-Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (CHS), Beyond the Rainbow , Hollywood Nebraska (Actors Theatre of Indiana), Joseph…, The Wizard of Oz (Booth Tarkington Civic Theatre). Appearances at The Grand Ole Opry and Feinstein’s. While attending CHS, Lizzie was a three year member of the competitive Show Choir, The Accents and the elite acapella group, Select Sound. 

Nathalie Cruz

Nathalie Cruz is thrilled to be back on ATI stage and joining this phenomenal performers! She was last seen on ATI’s production of A Grand Night of Singing. Other stage credits around town include: Small mouth sounds @American Lives Theatre, The Convent (swing) by Summit Performance Indianapolis ,Winston’s big day@ The Phoenix theatre, A Chorus Line, West Side story, Into the woods, Drowsy Chaperone, PIPPIN, Les Miz and Indy fringe The Gab. She’s a stylist by profession and loves to travel with her  amazing Cruz Zoo! Thank you for supporting local theater! Maraming Salamat!

Jill O’Malia

Jill O’Malia enjoys an active life as a businesswoman, actor, singer and director. Her singing and acting go back many years on both professional and amateur stages. Jill studied dance and voice at an early age, which gave her scholarship opportunities. After studying Fine Arts at Butler and traveling the United States as “Miss Indiana”, she found herself entertaining, emceeing events and modeling for Seventeen Magazine and Glamour. Jill has been fortunate to have played several leading lady roles, including the title roles in HELLO DOLLY, MAME, KISS ME KATE, and ANNIE GET YOUR GUN. Some of her other favorite roles include Maria in THE SOUND OF MUSIC. Mama Rose in GYPSY, the Witch in INTO THE WOODS, Velma in HAIRSPRAY, Tanya in MAMMA MIA and Paulette in LEGALLY BLONDE! She loves performing, but her favorite thing in life is enjoying family time with her husband, daughters and grandchildren.